Quick Links
-
Ron and Hermione Had a Turbulent Relationship
-
A Dark Theory Believes That Ron Cursed Hermione
-
There Are Major Holes in the Dark Ron Theory
It’s important to remember the ongoing controversial statements by the creator of the
Harry Potter
franchise. Efwebesupports the hard work of industry professionals on properties fans know and love, and the wider world of
Harry Potter
that fans have adopted as their own. You can find Efwebe’s continuing coverage on Rowling
here
.
Because the
Harry Potter
movies ended in 2011, the fan base has not had too much to discuss in the years after their conclusion. There were the
Fantastic Beasts
movies, but they proved to disappoint audiences and critics alike, leading to diminishing returns and ample criticism of the franchise. The
Cursed Child
play proved to be another potential avenue for discussion, but the plot inconsistencies and the lack of a theatrical adaptation meant that the fan base was largely restricted to those who watched the play on Broadway, in London, and other theaters around the globe. For many others, the Wizarding World seemingly ended when Harry (Daniel Radcliffe) sent Albus Severus Potter (Arthur Bowen) to Hogwarts for the first time.
The franchise is now set to enjoy a massive revival, thanks to an upcoming TV reboot. HBO hopes to introduce the
Harry Potter
world to the next generation, and it plans to do so with the help of an adaptation that is far more faithful to the books. The project is already divisive, given that author J.K. Rowling has become a lightning rod for controversy, given her comments about the LGBTQ+ community. The TV show has been the subject of sharp criticism since it was first announced, and the original movie series has also faced a similar fate. Many aspects of the franchise have been picked apart, and one of those divisive elements led to the creation of a truly dark theory about Ron and Hermione.
Ron and Hermione Had a Turbulent Relationship
The Films Were Not Entirely Loyal
Of all three
members of the Golden Triad
, Ron Weasley (Rupert Grint) and Hermione Granger (Emma Watson) had the most complicated relationship.
They began the story as enemies
, as Ron devoted much of
Harry Potter and the Magic Stone
(2001) mimicking Hermione’s assertive intelligence and her reputation for being a know-it-all. She would not hesitate to retaliate with sharp remarks, which frequently resulted in highly charged confrontations. Meanwhile, Harry, grappling with his personal issues, found himself constantly mediating disputes between his companions, as they were often embroiled in conflicts throughout the movies.
This does not foster a close and trustworthy bond, even if it might lead to a marriage down the line.
The situation deteriorated further when Ron blatantly bullied Hermione at the Yule Ball during
the 1994 Tri-Wizard Tournament
. Even though Hermione agreed to spend a nighttime with Viktor Krum (played by Stanislav Ianevski), Ron made sure she couldn’t overlook the ball, insisting that Krum was merely doing ”
using
Hermione. His remarks left her in tears as she sat on the stairs, contending that.
Ron had ”
spoiled everything
” for her
It was supposed to be one of the most memorable moments for Hermione this year, yet Ron turned it into something she could never fully appreciate. He acted as though she were nothing more than an undesirable item, always just Plan B, which made his reaction all the more crushing.
The two of them had a tumultuous relationship even outside those early days and the chaos of the Tri-Wizard Tournament. He mocked her abilities in
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
(2007), arguing that he ”
let
Hermione outsmarted him with
good manners
The two frequently quarrel, yet their exchanges never seem romantically charged. Rather, they dedicate considerable time to constant disputes.
They seldom experience genuine moments of connection.
, and when these moments occur, they frequently conclude with Hermione in tears. This situation does little to foster a close and trusting bond, despite the fact that their connection might eventually lead to marriage. Although the books portray a more realistic development of their relationship, the movies failed to accurately adapt this aspect.
A Sinister Hypothesis Suggests Ron Put a Curse on Hermione
It Would Explain Everything
Grasping the trajectory of their connection can be incredibly challenging due to its stormy character; however, an intriguing fan hypothesis sheds light on why Hermione leaned toward Ron. The theory posits that Hermione didn’t genuinely fall for Ron because she had become ensnared in a nefarious plot. Since Ron couldn’t persuade her into dating him, he ultimately opted to
covertly employ an Unforgivable Curse
against the person who would later become his partner. He chose to utilize the Imperio Curse for this purpose.
force Hermione to fall in love with him
.
The Reddit user formulated the theory after realizing that
Ron was able to use the Imperius curse
with ease when he was attempting to silence the goblin Bogrod. He never lost control of the spell, nor did he seem to strain by using it. This was a spell that Ron never truly had an opportunity to practice, so, curiously, he was able to adapt to it so quickly. Ron argued that he learned the spell from his father, Arthur Weasley (Mark Williams), but even that is not especially believable. After all, Arthur is far from the sort of wizard who relies on dark magic, and he would certainly not teach those spells to his own children.
Following the conclusion of the books, Hermione ultimately takes up the position of Minister for Magic, whereas Ron initially works as an Auror prior to joining his family’s enterprise at Weasleys’ Wizard Wheezes.
To address this puzzle, the user contended that Ron used a curse on Hermione to make her develop feelings for him. Supposedly feeling envious of Hermione’s attachment to Harry, Ron chose to vex Harry by potentially taking away a romantic interest.
The Slytherin’s Locket Horcrux
, after all, even indicated that Ron had difficulty accepting the notion of Hermione falling for Harry. Realizing he might lose her permanently, the argument suggests that Ron manipulated Hermione to stay aligned with him before employing the curse.
Order of the Phoenix
Although she wasn’t constantly under the curse’s influence, the theory suggests that
Ron would perform the incantation at brief intervals.
, gradually and inevitably shaping her thoughts.
There Are Significant Flaws in the Dark Ron Theory
He was likely just a terrible partner.
This theory could potentially turn Ron into one of the most detestable characters in the series, yet several significant flaws undermine this concept. After all, there isn’t any proof indicating that frequent use of the Imperius Curse has lasting effects capable of altering someone’s mental state permanently. For example, Barty Crouch Jr., portrayed by David Tennant, remained under the influence of the curse for an extended period without ever fully submitting to his father’s control.
Survivors also recall the impact of the curse.
Once it concludes, it doesn’t make much sense for Hermione not to catch onto Ron’s deception. Given her remarkable intelligence, she ought to readily identify the indications of a curse.
The central idea in this universe is that relationships devoid of love have dire outcomes.
Besides, there are far more accessible methods that could force others to fall in love.
Harry Potter
‘s horrifying love potions
, for instance, can compel a victim to fall in love without the concern of being caught by using an Unforgivable Curse. Ron certainly treated Hermione poorly in the movies, but
that is not proof that he is a dark wizard
A significant motif within this narrative is that relationships devoid of affection lead to severe repercussions, which were evident when Voldemort was born. However, these negative outcomes do not manifest in the current relationship being discussed. This absence itself suggests that their bond may indeed be genuine. It’s plausible that Hermione could have developed feelings for him regardless of his flaws—a phenomenon observed frequently in reality. Although imagining an antagonistic Ron presents intriguing possibilities, it seems unlikely that such a grim interpretation would hold up under scrutiny.